Editorial: When protesters come to church
Are you prepared for protesters to come to your church? Am I? I don’t want it to happen, but “want” is a different question.
There are different ways to be prepared and one that matters most. Amid the tension of our time and the prevalence of protest, we would do well to prepare in various ways for protesters to come to church. And we should do it before they arrive.
But whatever we do, we should prepare to communicate the gospel through both our words and actions. The gospel is the good news we are all looking for. It’s the good news we need.
Opinions about Sunday
Anti-ICE protesters interrupted a Sunday morning worship service in Minneapolis, Minn., Jan. 18. I doubt this is news to you. Social and traditional media have been flooded with the story, its repercussions, and people’s opinions.
You’ve probably already formed your opinion about the situation and those involved. You may have formed your opinion weeks before Jan. 18. Whether you support ICE or the protesters, or some mixture of the two, I’m not likely to change your opinion here, nor will I try.
I also am not making any judgement about Cities Church, the worshippers, the protesters, or the protest itself. Nor am I seeking to excuse or justify any of them, nor assess the truth of anything they said.
Rather, my aim is to challenge us to keep one thing primary—communicating the gospel through our words andactions should we find or put ourselves amid protest.
The gospel above opinions
Before going further, I know I am expected to say something about the rightness or wrongness of what happened inside Cities Church Sunday morning. Those who know me know I don’t have a simple one-or-the-other response to this.
To get into the weeds of who or what was right or wrong is to be distracted from the most important thing Christians need to focus on in a situation like this.
The most important thing Christians need to do amid protest is communicate the good news about Jesus through our words and actions.
From a purely legal standpoint, three great freedoms collided inside the sanctuary of Cities Church on Jan. 18. The First Amendment guarantees (1) the free exercise of religion, (2) the freedom of speech, and (3) the freedom to peaceably assemble. From a legal standpoint, this is a fascinating case, and the law is already responding.
But Sunday’s incident wasn’t a purely legal event. It was a moral and religious event with moral and religious implications. Again, I won’t get into the weeds of those implications. My focus here is on our need to be ready to communicate the gospel through our words and actions in whatever situation arises.
Prepare by practicing the gospel
As wonderful as the gospel is, it is an uncomfortable thing. The gospel is both the comfort of salvation in Jesus Christ and the discomfort of turning the other cheek. It is both the comfort of grace and the discomfort of denying ourselves. These are just two among many uncomfortable truths of the gospel.
The uncomfortable parts of the gospel don’t come easy to us. They require practice. Yes, the Holy Spirit lives in us and empowers us to speak and live out the gospel. And we still have to train the vocabulary and behavior of the gospel into ourselves.
What comes easy is clenching our jaw, pointing our finger, judging each other. It’s easier to belittle and berate one another, to question the other person’s commitment to the gospel. We don’t have to practice that. We do have to practice Christlikeness.
To prepare for protest, we must engage in the Christian life. The Christian life isn’t just gathering to sing hymns and spiritual songs, read Scripture, and hear a sermon. It is also engaging in active spiritual formation—discipleship—together, helping each other become more and more Christlike.
To learn the gospel, we need to study the Gospels. We need to study Jesus’ teachings and commands, meditate on them, and practice them. We need to study and practice how he interacted with all the different people he encountered. Some were protesters. Some were protested. Jesus offered good news to them all. He still does. It’s our duty to communicate it.
Practical considerations
The gospel’s primacy does not mean there’s nothing else churches need to do. There are practical ways churches should prepare themselves for protest. These ways should be consistent with the gospel.
Churches need to figure out how they will respond to protests on, around, or inside their facilities before those protests ever happen.
Protests can easily escalate. What begins as a peaceful, though disruptive, protest can take a violent turn quickly and without warning. For this reason and others, churches need a safety and security plan, and they need to develop it and practice it before it’s needed.
Some things have changed since 2018 when we published guidance for church safety and security teams. One thing hasn’t. Churches need to make sure their safety and security measures are on the right side of the law before those measures are implemented.
Should a situation arise calling for the deployment of these measures, churches also need to be prepared to respond to questions about how their measures square with the church’s proclamation of the gospel. Don’t wait until something happens to try to figure that out.
Likewise, churches should assume something will happen at some point involving their ministry or facilities that will draw media attention. Churches need to prepare for that also before it happens.
All the while, churches need to engage their participants in actively becoming more and more like Christ.
For all situations, the most important thing churches need to do is be ready to communicate the gospel of Jesus Christ through our words and our actions. To be ready, we need to practice now.
Eric Black is the executive director, publisher and editor of the Baptist Standard. He can be reached at eric.black@baptiststandard.com. The views expressed in this opinion article are those of the author.