Christian love for the poor demands deeper commitment than charity
WACO—Even in Christian circles, response to economic injustice easily can be based on worldly charity rather than the heart of Christ, two Baylor University professors told the No Need Among You conference.
Natalie Carnes, assistant professor of theology, and Jonathan Tran, associate professor of theology and ethics, discussed what Christian discipleship demands and how it relates to worldly charity and Christian love.
![]() Unlike the world's response to poverty, Christian love causes Christ's followers to see everything they have as a gift of God, granted so it can be given to those in need, Baylor University professor Jonathan Tran told the No Need Among You conference.
|
"In (Waco), a city where one out of three people live below the poverty line, in a state teeming with folks who feel the need to fight—often with one another—for scarce resources, in a nation that suffers recession where millions go unemployed … in a world where 35,000 children die daily from poverty, where hundreds of millions live on less than a $1 a day and eat less than a bowl of rice, we are very, very rich," Tran said.
And from this material abundance, Christ calls his followers to give and care for the poor. But even among Christians, this call typically is answered with what he termed "worldly charity"—so called because the majority of the world responds in that manner and is a model of goodness rooted in the world.
"The fact that we Christians tend to applaud this kind of charity, that we tend to aspire to it, shows that we are worldly, if by worldly we mean resembling, not distinguishable from, non-Christian people in the world," Tran said.
Worldly charity requires some response, but it does not demand the same deep level of commitment as Christian love, Carnes noted.
"Worldly charity requires sacrifice but not deep sacrifice, compassion but not overwhelming compassion, a global consideration of poverty without a global indictment of systems that create poverty. Worldly charity allows us to believe God is on the side of the rich and that we can continue living in the same general patterns that we always lived," Carnes said.
![]() Christian love demands self-sacrifice and a greater level of commitment than worldly charity, Baylor University professor Natalie Carnes told the No Need Among You conference. (PHOTOS/Kaitlin Warrington/BGCT)
|
On the surface, worldly charity looks appealing and adequate, Tran said. But with a deeper look, it is far from the call of discipleship and example of Christian charity that Christ gave.
Christian charity recognizes that apart from God, Christ-followers have nothing, he added. All is seen as a gift of God with the intention of giving away the blessings to those in need.
Christian charity "requires, not the giving of a few coins or the jacket we no longer wear, but that we also give away a sizable chunk of our bank account—maybe even more than we keep—and that we also give away items we may love, even need," Carnes said.
This type of charity means Christ-followers examine all parts of life, being willing to sacrifice convenience and comfort to give to people who have little or nothing.
"Christian charity swims in an ocean of compassion that flows from the life of God and floods our lives and choices," Carnes said.
"Where worldly charity allows your life to remain intact, Christian charity, with its life-drenching compassion, will not. It will inconvenience your life. It will trouble you. It doesn't ask what spare change you have, but rather, 'How have you lived in such a way that you have so much spare change around?'"
Christian charity comes at a cost, but Christ-followers can be sure they are following the heart of God in this sacrifice.
"I have said that we cannot worship the God who made the poor without serving the poor. I might also say that we cannot worship the God who gave everything if we demand to hold on to our things," Carnes said.