Deriving principles from Acts 10-11, Julio Guarneri grounded Texas Baptist history in the authority of Scripture: “Texas Baptists believe the Bible. We are a people of the book. Do not let anyone deceive you otherwise.”
The Baptist General Convention of Texas’ history is a source of strength for the convention’s present and future, BGCT Executive Director Guarneri told BGCT Executive Board members during their February meeting.
Reflecting on the convention’s 140-year legacy and the account of Peter’s vision leading to Cornelius’ conversion, Guarneri called for future growth, renewed vision, and increased cooperation.
Formed around cooperation
Noting there were five Baptist groups in Texas in the mid- to late-1800s, Guarneri said the vision of the BGCT’s founders “was one of cooperation for the sake of God’s mission.” Doctrinal conformity was not an organizing principle, he asserted.
“While Baptist distinctives, including sound doctrine, have always been important, the BGCT did not organize around doctrinal conformity,” Guarneri said.
Similarly, the Southern Baptist Convention, formed in 1845, did not have a convention-wide statement of faith until 1925, Guarneri pointed out.
According to a quote Guarneri shared from William W. Barnes, Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary professor, the 1925 statement of faith was not uniformly adopted by Southern Baptists.
The 1925 statement was revised in 1963 and again in 2000.
Lack of “doctrinal centralization,” as Barnes phrased it in 1934, did not mean Southern Baptists nor Texas Baptists questioned the authority of Scripture, Guarneri explained.
However, during the decades-long Southern Baptist controversy that led, in part, to the 2000 revision of the Baptist Faith and Message, the word “inerrancy” became a litmus test for one’s view of Scripture.
Authority of Scripture
Guarneri directly addressed “chatter” about inerrancy, specifically, the assertion other conventions are committed to inerrancy while the BGCT has “a low view of the authority” of Scripture and that only those who affirm the 2000 Baptist Faith and Message believe in inerrancy.
The words “inerrant” or “inerrancy” are not in either the 1963 or the 2000 statements, Guarneri pointed out, comparing “Article I: The Scriptures” in the 1963 and 2000 statements.
Both versions of the statement, following the 1925 statement nearly verbatim, read:
“The Holy Bible was written by men divinely inspired [and] is a perfect treasure of divine instruction. It has God for its author, salvation for its end, and truth, without any mixture of error, for its matter. It reveals the principles by which God judges us; and therefore is, and will remain to the end of the world, the true center of Christian union, and the supreme standard by which all human conduct, creeds, and religious opinions should be tried.”
Article I of the 1963 and 2000 statements are not identical but are very similar, Guarneri acknowledged. Differences between the two appear in the first and last sentences.
“Those who suggest the conventions and churches who affirm the 2000 version [of the Baptist Faith and Message] are committed to inerrancy, in contrast with those who [affirm the] 1963 [version], are either ignorant or dishonest, because the word [inerrant] is not there,” Guarneri stated.
“I would argue … our commitment to the authority of the Scriptures is higher than others, because we do not elevate man-made confessions of faith above the Bible,” Guarneri contended. “If your conscience is going to submit to anything, let it be to the scriptures of the Old and New Testament, not to a man-made confession of faith. That’s where we stand.”
Cooperation amid polarization
“Today, we are surrounded by a culture of tribalism,” Guarneri said. “People are emotionally invested in their tribe … around politics, or religious beliefs, or ethical issues. … The tendency is to see others that are not in full agreement with me as the enemy and to attack them and to demean them and perhaps even dehumanize them,” he continued.
Sadly, this tribalism has crept into churches, resulting in people making decisions based around labels, Guarneri added.
“We need to be different [from] the culture around us,” Guarneri asserted. “We need to return to our commitment of cooperation.”
Guarneri also addressed declining Cooperative Program receipts, saying the 25-year decline in BGCT Cooperative Program receipts is not unique. The SBC Cooperative Program receipts have been declining for 35 years, he said.
Guarneri attributed the decline, in part, to increased inflation reducing the buying power at the same time costs have increased. Also, churches are sending less Cooperative Program dollars to the BGCT and SBC as their receipts decline and needs and costs increase.
“Our response should be to neither fear nor fixate on the dollars … nor lament the ways things used to be,” he said.
Rather, he proposed four things based on Acts 10-11 for ministries to focus on instead: The biblical foundation for cooperation, the legacy of cooperation as a Baptist people, prayer for God to reawaken churches, and a commitment to collaborate for the sake of the kingdom.
Unity amid diversity
Citing Numbers 2:2, how the Israelite tribes were to camp around the tabernacle, each family under their own banner, Guarneri asserted: “The church today would honor God most and would be most effective with every local congregation retaining their identity, their autonomy, their uniqueness, and recognizing that we together are one body in Christ.”
“We don’t have to agree on everything to be on mission together. We are called to unity in diversity for the sake of God’s glory,” he continued.
“Sound doctrine is important. We must agree on orthodox Christian doctrine. We must hold up Baptist distinctives, but we must give room for diversity in secondary and tertiary doctrines,” Guarneri said, noting Texas Baptist churches differ over Calvinism and Arminianism, end-times views, Communion, and women in ministry.
Though Texas Baptists interpret some of these matters differently, “what is constant is our commitment to the authority, inspiration, sufficiency, and infallibility of the Holy Scriptures,” Guarneri contended.
In all his travel around Texas and meeting with hundreds of Texas Baptist pastors, he has not yet met a pastor in Texas who doesn’t believe the Bible is authoritative and infallible, he added.
“Let us rise up and claim our identity, our legacy as a Baptist people who cooperate together,” Guarneri encouraged Executive Board members. “One hundred and forty years of cooperation for God’s mission, the Great Commandment, and the Great Commission demand it, and the glory of God is worthy of it.”
This report does not follow the exact chronology of Julio Guarneri’s address.