Texas children deserve quality education, commission says_30804
Posted: 3/05/04
Texas children deserve quality education, commission says
By Ferrell Foster
Texas Baptist Communications
DALLAS–After hearing a leading Texas educator say the state is at a “great watershed moment,” the Christian Life Commission of the Baptist General Convention of Texas voted unanimously to approve several proposals related to school finance, including opposition to gambling and school vouchers.
Commissioners also instructed CLC Director Phil Strickland to “urgently request an immediate meeting” with Gov. Rick Perry.
Strickland reported that up to this point the governor has not responded to the CLC director's efforts to arrange a meeting regarding the school finance, vouchers and gambling issues.
Texas political leaders are in the midst of trying to work out a solution to the state's school finance woes.
The effort may lead to a special called meeting of the Legislature as early as March 29.
Several circumstances have conspired to create the situation.
Last year, the Legislature voted to kill “Robin Hood,” which had forced more wealthy school districts to share money with poorer ones.
Also, there is a state limit on local property taxes that fund much of today's education expenses, and many school districts already have reached that limit.
The result is a need for more state revenue, and a number of tax proposals are being considered.
The CLC did not endorse a particular solution but rather adopted a number of principles to guide the CLC staff in regard to public education and school finance.
It did, however, vote that increased gambling revenue should not be considered as an option.
Prior to the commission's decisions, Mike Moses, superintendent of the Dallas Independent School District and former state commissioner of education, addressed the CLC and the board of Texans Against Gambling.
“We're talking serious business here” as the state deals with this “watershed moment,” he said.
Moses hopes the state will seek long-term solutions, not short-term answers.
With the state's “exploding minority population” and the English language deficiencies that come with heavy immigration, the state's economic future is in jeopardy if it does not provide the funding needed to maintain an educated and trained population, Moses said.
Suzii Paynter, the CLC's director of citizenship and public policy, said Baptists have a “moral obligation to see that Texas provides all children with a quality education.” And beyond that, it “makes good business sense to see that Texas public schools produce an educated work force.”
It's “far better to push now for real legislative reform than to further delay and risk” facing an even greater problem in the future, not just in school finance but state financing in general, she said.
“The Legislature listens when business and community leaders speak with a united voice.”
In taking official action, commissioners voted to “strongly” oppose the expansion of gambling in the state. Cost-benefit studies “clearly show” that legalized gambling costs $3 for every $1 of revenue it produces, the motion stated.
The CLC approved another motion “strongly” opposing the use of vouchers to fund religious education with tax dollars on the basis of religious liberty and the separation of church and state.
Yet another motion instructed the CLC director to “convene a special committee to study the impact of a state income tax.” The commission took no position on the issue.
Strickland told commissioners he envisions the committee including people from other faith groups, as well as business leaders.
The commission voted to approve two lists of priorities that will guide the CLC.
The priorities regarding public education are:
Maintain equity and adequacy, which are constitutional requirements.
Provide adequate education along with adequate funding.
Fund a substantial portion of school costs from state tax revenues.
Achieve major property tax relief.
Require additional school funding to be directed toward improving student performance.
Maintain a school property tax levy to promote local control and accountability.
Provide reasonable student cost adjustments.
Permit “unequalized local enrichment” with limits.
Priorities regarding public school financing include:
New tax revenues should be drawn from a combination of taxes to spread the burden.
Current inequities in the state tax system should be fixed.
Individuals should continue to bear a fair share of the school tax burden.
New taxes on business should be ones that “would not materially adversely affect” the economy.
New taxes on business should be “reasonably passed on in the marketplace.”
New taxes should grow with the state's growth.
Gambling revenue should not be part of the public school funding formula.
