Worship–carefully blended or just bland?_72505
Posted: 7/22/05
Worship–carefully blended or just bland?
By Ken Camp
Managing Editor
Like a blank screen on which people project their own ideas, blended worship has become a catchall term that defies easy definition.
Music Minister Chuck Bridwell of Columbus Avenue Baptist Church in Waco attended a conference for worship leaders a couple of years ago. A seminar leader invited a dozen participants to introduce themselves and tell about the worship styles of their churches.
“All of them said their churches had blended worship,” he recalled. “I knew several of them, and I knew how different they were from each other.”
| Clell Wright, head of the church music department at Hardin-Simmons University, teaches aspiring church musicians a variety of styles.Photo courtesy of Hardin-Simmons University |
Bridwell, who has been at Columbus Avenue six years, describes worship services at his church as “hymn-based blended.” At University Baptist Church in Coral Gables, Fla., where he served 24 years, the blended service leaned more toward praise and worship contemporary music, with one or two hymns included.
Trent Blackley, minister of music at First Baptist Church in Sunnyvale, described the worship services he helps to plan as blended, but he acknowledged they can vary widely from one week to the next.
If members “hang on long enough,” most will be satisfied one Sunday and have “ruffled feathers” another week, he said.
“I try not to pay attention to counting how many hymns or how many choruses are in any given worship service,” Blackley said. He views different musical styles as varied colors on a palette he can use to paint an environment for worship.
“Most of our services have a central theme. I choose from my palette what I think is the best that can be brought to reinforce the message,” he said.
Randall Bradley, church music professor at Baylor University, prefers that kind of intentionality in blended worship to the lowest-common-denominator approach some churches follow.
“There are all kinds of blends. There's the blend where all of the components retain their distinctive qualities, or there's the kind where it's all mellowed out, bland and colorless,” he said.
“It's the difference between a plate of carrots, peas and other vegetables that retain their distinctive colors and flavors, as opposed to what happens when they're mixed together in a bowl of soup.”
Bradley pointed to the need for connecting elements–a subtle theme, a logical progression and a narrative flow–that bring together diverse worship elements into a unified whole.
“Blended can mean woven together carefully with points of connection. It's like a patchwork quilt of distinctive elements, drawn together into a pattern with connections that bring it all together,” he said. The alternative is “blended as in a blender, where it all comes out as mush.”
Clell Wright, head of the church music department at Hardin-Simmons University, doesn't like the “blended worship” label.
“It indicates a watering down of styles and genres. When you blend ingredients into a cake, you mix them and they lose their identity. It carries a negative connotation of trying to appease a certain group,” Wright said.
“Instead, I believe we should celebrate diversity in worship. Realize the body of Christ worldwide is diverse. Different cultural backgrounds, different ethnic backgrounds all are appropriate and can be used in worship.”
Even so, he does not suggest a wholesale, rapid shift from familiar gospel songs or traditional hymns to a worship style that seems totally alien to a congregation.
“We worship God out of the background of who we are. We are shaped by culture. First, we worship God out of that which is familiar to us,” Wright said.
“We have to be comfortable in the language in which we worship God, and music is a language. … The makeup of the congregation should be reflected in the way they worship.”
Each congregation will express worship in its own way, said Tim Studstill, director of the Baptist General Convention of Texas Center for Music and Worship.
“Each congregation has a different language of worship, and there are many different dialects of worship. Many congregations need to be taught a new vocabulary of worship so that they may more fully express their worship to the Lord,” Studstill said.
“This vocabulary consists of contemporary music, great hymns of the faith, new music that is appropriate for a specific congregation and every style in-between.”
To discover the right blend appropriate for a given congregation, a worship leader must know the congregation well, said Bradley, who serves a worship leader at Calvary Baptist Church in Waco in addition to teaching at Baylor.
“All worship planning is pastoral,” he said. “The task is to bring God to people you know and love deeply. … You can't take worship from church A and impose it on church B. Worship planning needs to be within the context of community. It is for these people on this day at this point in history–not just dropped in.”



