Posted: 5/14/04
Proposed SBC resolution calls for
withdrawal from public education
By Bob Allen
EthicsDaily.com
The Southern Baptist Convention may consider a resolution urging parents to pull their children out of public schools and educate them either by home schooling or sending them to Christian private schools.
T.C. Pinckney, long-time conservative leader from Virginia, has jointly submitted a resolution on Christian education to the SBC Resolutions Committee. The committee will consider whether to present it for a vote when the convention meets June 15-16 in Indianapolis.
The resolution urges all officers and members of the Southern Baptist Convention “to remove their children from the government schools and see to it that they receive a thoroughly Christian education.”
A proposed resolution to the Southern Baptist Convention encourages churches to "counsel parents regarding their obligation to provide their children with a Christian education" and to "provide all of their children with Christian alternatives to government school education, either through home schooling or thoroughly Christian private schools." |
It encourages churches to “counsel parents regarding their obligation to provide their children with a Christian education” and to “provide all of their children with Christian alternatives to government school education, either through home schooling or thoroughly Christian private schools.”
The resolution's co-sponsor, Bruce Shortt, an attorney and member of North Oaks Baptist Church in Spring, told the conservative Web site WorldNetDaily.com many Christian parents are in denial about the dangers of government schools.
The time has come “to focus on rescuing our children from Pharaoh's schools,” Shortt maintained.
The resolution does not disparage adults who “labor as missionaries” by working or teaching in public schools. Rather, “they should be commended and encouraged to be salt and light in a dark and decaying government school system,” it says.
The convention previously passed resolutions favoring home schooling in 1997 and Christian schools in 1999 as alternatives to public education. But the new resolution, should it win approval, would be the first to label it a Christian duty to abandon public schools.
Shortt is Texas coordinator for Exodus Mandate, an anti-public school movement started in 1997 with the mantra, “Every church a school, every parent a teacher.”
The new resolution submitted by Pinckney and Shortt says the public school system, while claiming to be neutral toward religion, “is actually anti-Christian, so that children taught in the government schools are receiving an anti-Christian education.”
Education offered by state-run schools “is officially godless,” the resolution says, and public schools are adopting curricula and policies “teaching that a homosexual lifestyle is acceptable.”
“Whereas the Bible says children are like arrows in the hand of a warrior (Psalm 127:3-5), we must understand that children are weapons (arrows) to be aimed for the greatest impact in the kingdom of God,” the proposed resolution states.
“Just as it would be foolish for the warrior to give his arrows to his enemies, it is foolish for Christians to give their children to be trained in schools run by the enemies of God.”
The resolution says the Bible gives parents the responsibility for educating their children, yet Christian children in public schools “are converted to an anti-Christian worldview rather than evangelizing their schoolmates.”
That is one factor, the resolution claims, behind the statistic that 88 percent of children raised in evangelical homes leave church by age 18, never to return.
Pinckney said the SBC needs to adopt the resolution for three reasons: “Because God's word assigns responsibility for the children's education to the parents, not the government; because Southern Baptists are the largest Protestant denomination in America and so our decisions carry considerable influence not just for Southern Baptists but for the country at large;” and because “government schools are fatally flawed academically, morally, fiscally and are anti-Christian.”
Shortt said many parents have been “spiritually blind” not only to their responsibility to see to their children's education but also to the dangers of turning that task over to “government” schools, he said.
Baptists who object that Christians shouldn't “turn their back” on public education fall prey to “a mistaken application of … (being) salt and light,” he said.
While Jesus sent his disciples into the world, Shortt said, they were adults and spiritually prepared.
While he has no problem with adults who want to teach in public schools to bring a Christian witness to bear, Shortt said, youth are not ready for such a responsibility.
Robert Parham with the Baptist Center for Ethics criticized the anti-public school movement as “racist in its roots” and bearing “false witness with its agenda.”
The anti-public school movement in the 1960s “was fed from pulpits that used the Bible to support segregation,” Parham said.
“Not surprisingly, churches planted white race academies, which sought racial purity.”
Today's “spiritual heirs of the race academies now advance the cause of religious purity,” Parham said.
“The first generation bore false witness against public schools with the demonization of African-Americans,” Parham said.
“The latter bears false witness with utterly malicious charges of godlessness in our community schools.”
Shortt disputed Parham's allegations, noting African Americans are the fastest growing demographic in the home schooling movement.
He pointed to a Tennessee university survey showing ethnic minorities are almost twice as likely as Anglos to say they would consider home schooling their children.
“Perhaps Mr. Parham is unacquainted with the fact that government schools do their greatest damage to black students,” Shortt said.
Social progressives and Ku Klux Klan members alike were advocates of church-state separation and “strong proponents of government schools well into the 20th century,” he said.
“Perhaps Mr. Parham needs to apply himself to some serious research and thinking rather than engaging in name-calling with respect to someone he does not know,” said Shortt, who noted his three sons are biracial. “I don't mind fair comment and disagreement, but the decent thing to do would be to retract the attempted smear.”
Southern Baptist Convention President Jack Graham says he supports Christian education but doubts Southern Baptists will adopt the proposed resolution urging parents to pull their children out of public schools.
Parents should make a “fully informed decision” about their children's education, said Graham, pastor of Prestonwood Baptist Church in Plano.
“I doubt the SBC will approve a statement which urges parents to remove their children from public schools,” Graham said.
Should the resolutions committee decide not to bring the resolution forward, Pinckey said either he or Shortt probably would request from the floor that messengers be allowed to debate and vote on the measure. Such a motion would have to pass by a two-thirds majority.
But Shortt said whether the resolution passes is less important to him than drawing attention to an already-growing movement of home schooling and starting Christian schools.
“We're trying to raise the issue in a general way, because this issue needs to come full front-and-center, not just among leadership, but among the laity as well,” he said. “That's the reason why this resolution ought to get to the floor.”
News of religion, faith, missions, Bible study and Christian ministry among Texas Baptist churches, in the BGCT, the Southern Baptist Convention ( SBC ) and around the world.