EDITORIAL: Our next president should restore civility to America_110104
Posted: 10/29/04
EDITORIAL:
Our next president should restore civility to America
The past few weeks, have you sometimes felt battered and bruised when you clicked your TV set off? Did your ears feel assaulted as you left your business breakroom or lunchtime diner? Have you had a tension headache after Sunday school? Did your pulse pound when you read the letters to the editor in this newspaper?
You know what I'm talking about: Incivility anxiety. It's the ferocious unease millions of Americans have suffered because of this down-and-dirty political season.
If you've traveled in any of the so-called battleground states, you've seen this played out. TV ads have competed for voters, challenging them to choose George W. Bush or John Kerry. And from what we hear, most of those ads have taken the low road, mongering fear and suspicion for the sake of ballots. Although no one doubts where Texas' electoral college votes will go, we haven't been exempt from the mayhem. Thanks to re-gerrymandered congressional districts, we've heard incumbents verbally bludgeon one another for the opportunity to return to Washington and represent us in Congress.
| Whether it's George W. Bush or John Kerry, our next president better give attention to restoring civility to America. It's a moral, spiritual, political and social problem that deserves his best efforts. |
The TV and radio attack ads would have been enough. But rank-and-file Americans seem to think they have to speak and act as venally as the candidates themselves. In our neck of the woods, we've seen a rash of vandalism against political yard signs. That's about the most polite political practice around here. You couldn't go far–to the grocery store, a restaurant, even church–without hearing the kind of partisan political opponent-bashing that would make Rush Limbaugh blush. If you've been listening, you've probably heard people ask, “How can you call yourself a Christian and vote for …” more in the past two months than in the previous two decades. And it's gotten personal. Stories abound about friends and family who have practically stopped talking to each other because they can't avoid arguments over politics and parties and candidates and issues.
That's a big reason why I'm worried about America. Of course, we've got plenty of other reasons for concern–the ever-present threat of terrorism, a war that's not going well, a sputtering economy, an educational system that's failing millions of children, ominous clouds hanging over the health care system, crippling poverty, and on and on. But the most insidious problem facing the United States–and our next president, whether it's Bush or Kerry–is the corrosive incivility eating away at our social and moral infrastructure. To quote the plaintive plea of Rodney King, “Why can't we all get along?” And if we can't re-learn to get along, how can we expect to tame the monstrous problems howling at our national door?
So, although homeland security and the Iraq war will clamor for the attention of the president elected Nov. 2, he better give attention to restoring civility to America. It's a moral, spiritual, political and social problem that deserves his best efforts. Here are some places to start:
Form a bipartisan cabinet. Surely, some Republicans and Democrats are secure, sensible and self-sacrificing enough to step up, if asked by the president, and sit on a cabinet headed by the other party. A collegial, bipartisan cabinet could set the tone for civil discourse, compromise and shared vision that could lead ordinary Americans back together.
(Lest you think this never would work, remember how a bipartisan Governor Bush worked with Democrats as his Republican administration guided Texas. This is the kind of affirmative leadership many voters thought they would get when they cast their ballots in 2000.)
Work on common goals. Find a couple of issues around which all Americans can rally and create models for mutual concern and partnership that can achieve lasting results.
For example, almost everyone knows health care needs help. The next president could convene a panel that (a) acknowledges the legitmate interests of doctors, insurance companies and health care providers but also (b) places the health interests of individual Americans above all else. If such a problem-solving team could succeed, it could demonstrate that other challenges can be overcome–if we cooperate civilly. And if health care is too tough, convene a similar problem-solving team to improve our transportation system. Anbody who has to go from Point A to Point B in America knows we can, and should, do better.
Fix a tough problem. We're failing on abortion because we've framed the issue incorrectly. Right now, it's presented as legal question of women's rights. It ought to be a common question of reducing, and ideally eliminating, abortions.
I don't know a pro-choice advocate who wants to see the abortion total increase. We need to reduce all the causes of abortion, not just the eliminate the legality of abortion. An abortion-reduction policy ought to focus on education, jobs, child care, adoption, marriage and the web of issues that influence the abortion rate. Pro-life advocates have been vexed when they come to the end of seemingly supportive presidents' terms and abortion rates have increased and they've made no progress. It's time to be pragmatic about abortion; rather than grasping for a judicial goal that may prove as elusive as the Holy Grail, work with all people of goodwill–whatever their stand on the legality of abortion–to bring the abortion rate closer and closer and closer to zero.
Say the hard, but correct, things. Wouldn't it be refreshing to hear politicians from opposing parties say, “You know, I think we agree on that” or “You're doing a good job”? What would happen if a president said: “I was wrong, and I've learned my lesson. Help me do better this time”?
Call me a Pollyanna or a Christian with misplaced faith, but I think these ideas could work. No matter if George Bush or John Kerry lives in the White House. And along the way, a more civil America would be a far, far better place to live.
–Marv Knox
E-mail the editor at marvknox@baptiststandard.com





