Waller prescribes dose of humility for preachers with dubious doctorates_20904
Posted: 2/06/04
Waller prescribes dose of humility
for preachers with dubious doctorates
By George Henson
Staff Writer
GORDONVILLE–Some pastors touting the title “Dr.” before their names need a refresher course in ethics, according to a paper awaiting publication in the journal Christian Higher Education.
The treatise by Rusty Waller, bivocational pastor of First Baptist Church in Gordonville, is titled “Higher Education Credentials of American Clergy: Ethics or Antics?”
In addition to being a pastor, Waller is dean of institutional research and effectiveness at North Central Texas College in Gainesville, where he ensures the college meets regional accreditation standards.
Waller also helped Baptist University of the Americas achieve certification from the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board to grant undergraduate degrees. Baptist University of the Americas also earned a certificate of accreditation from the Accrediting Association of Bible Colleges.
When it comes to graduate-level education, regional accreditation is important because it provides a clear standard of academic requirements, Waller contends.
Attorneys, teachers, architects, doctors and other professionals are required to earn degrees from regionally accredited schools, he noted. Such accreditation indicates the level of scholarship mandated to attain the degree.
So when a pastor begins calling himself “Dr.” when he does not hold an accredited doctoral degree, it hurts his witness, Waller contends.
“Pastors need to be aware that the use of the title 'Dr.' without having a regionally accredited degree is deeply offensive to those in other professions who have to work to maintain their credentials,” he explained.
Waller said he first considered writing on this topic as he saw televangelists taking on the title “Dr.” He was unable to ascertain the source of most their degrees, he said, “which tells me it's a very bogus situation.”
His investigation revealed a number of places where an unaccredited doctoral diploma can be secured for a minimal amount of cash. One site for the Progressive Universal Life Church currently will throw in a doctor of divinity degree for free if a doctor of philosophy in either religion or theology is ordered for $175.
Waller went a step further, however, and decided to see what he could determine about the credentials of a sample of Baptist General Convention of Texas pastors.
He sent questionnaires to 200 pastors whose churches matched a representative sample of the size and ethnicity of the convention.
Only 105 of those surveys were returned, of which 35 pastors claimed doctoral degrees. Seven of those 35 doctorates, 20 percent, came from non-regionally accredited doctoral programs.
Waller said he would stop short of saying only 20 percent of the sample had degrees from non-regionally accredited schools, however, because only 52 percent of the pastors in the pool responded.
“I have questions about the non-respondents and where their credentials are from,” he said.
“I would speculate that those who returned their questionnaires didn't see anything wrong with having non-regionally accredited degrees.”
He postulates that some who did not respond may have been more aware.
But he does acknowledge a wide spectrum of sources of non-regionally accredited degrees, “from the most bogus of diploma mills to actual institutions” of merit.
At the high end of that spectrum, Waller places Luther Rice Seminary, the most common source of non-regionally accredited degrees among those surveyed.
However, while not a place to buy a diploma without study, the independent seminary should not be viewed on an even par with fully accredited seminaries such as Logsdon School of Theology at Hardin-Simmons University or Baylor University's Truett Theological Seminary, he asserted.
Luther Rice Seminary is accredited by the Transnational Association of Christian Colleges and Schools, a certification that requires less strenuous examination than that offered by regional commissions such as the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools.
The United States Department of Education views TRACS on the same level as the Association of Theological Schools, the nation's primary accrediting agency for graduate-level theological education.
However, both Logsdon and Truett are accredited not only by ATS on the national level but by SACS on the regional level.
And to Waller's perspective as an educator, that makes a huge difference.
“Other professions require doctorates from regionally accredited institutions,” he said. “Why should pastors settle for less?”
Waller does not suggest that a regionally accredited degree should be a requirement for the pastorate, or that the education that can be gained at some schools, such as Luther Rice, is not without merit.
“I have no problem with a person pursuing an education wherever they choose, but I do have a problem with them putting 'Dr.' in front of their name” if they do not hold a regionally accredited degree, he said.
That especially is true if a pastor knowingly obtains a degree not acquired by scholarship on the doctoral level, Waller said.
“Credentials without education can only be for men to look at.”
Likewise, it is unethical for a pastor who receives an honorary doctorate, such a doctor of divinity degree, to affix “Dr.” to his name, Waller said.
Reading his paper probably won't change the minds of those who already have secured non-accredited degrees, Waller admitted. But he does hope to impact future decisions.
“I don't really think writing this will stop anyone who is using the title 'Dr.' from using it, but I hope that some young pastors out there considering this will get their doctorates from regionally accredited institutions,” he said.
“I've been a pastor from 29 years, but I can understand how a young man might look and see that he can have a doctorate here for $700, and over there it's going to take years of commitment and ask, 'What's my motivation to do that?' if they don't understand all the issues.”
